Many operators of semi-automated motor vehicles drive as if their autos are fully automated, despite the crash risks of doing so, according to a study released Tuesday by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS).
The study, based on a survey of 600 users of Cadillac’s Super Cruise system, Nissan/Infiniti’s ProPilot system, and Tesla’s Autopilot system, found the drivers were more likely to perform non-driving activities, like eating or texting, while using the driver assistance systems.
On top of that, more than half the Super Cruise drivers (52%), two out of five Autopilot drivers (42%), and 12% of ProPilot drivers told surveyors they were comfortable treating their vehicles as full self-driving autos.
“The big-picture message here is that the early adopters of these systems still have a poor understanding of the technology’s limits,” IIHS President David Harkey said in a statement.
“It’s possible that system design and marketing are adding to these misconceptions,” he added.
The IIHS isn’t alone in finding gaps in consumer understanding of the capabilities of driver-assistance technology. Studies by J.D. Power, a consumer research, data, and analytics firm based in Troy, Mich., have yielded similar results.
“We found 56% of consumers classifying driver-assisted technology available today as fully-automated self-driving,” said JDP’s Senior Manager of Auto Benchmarking and Mobility Development, Lisa Boor.
“That’s concerning because we know that those systems today are meant to assist the driver,” she told TechNewsWorld. “The driver still has overall responsibility for the vehicle.”
The IIHS explained that current partial automation systems assist drivers through adaptive cruise control — which can regulate speed to maintain a safe distance behind a vehicle — and lane centering, which keeps a vehicle centered in its travel lane.
It noted that the existing systems are not designed to replace human drivers or make it safe for them to perform other tasks that take their focus from the road. Track tests and real-world crashes have provided ample evidence that the systems struggle to recognize and react to common driving situations and road features, it added.
Marketing may be a factor contributing to consumer misunderstanding about the capabilities of computer-assisted driving systems.
“Tesla, because of the way they’ve marketed Autopilot over the years and Elon Musk has talked about Autopilot, has created the impression that these types of systems are far more capable than they really are,” said Sam Abuelsamid, principal analyst for e-mobility at Guidehouse Insights, a market intelligence company in Detroit.
“Because Musk is put forward by a lot of people in the media as a genius, people are inclined to believe him, even though a lot of what he says is nonsense,” he told TechNewsWorld.
Gartner Vice President and Analyst for Automotive and Smart Mobility Mike Ramsey agreed that marketing has played a role in consumer expectations about driver assistance systems. “Tesla names its system Autopilot, which implies the vehicle will fly itself,” he told TechNewsWorld.
“It’s implied that the vehicle is driving itself,” he added. “It’s not really driving itself. It’s essentially cruise control with extra functionality.”
The way these systems are designed, they don’t put firm boundaries on driver behavior, so drivers don’t know what they can and cannot do, observed IIHS research scientist and report author Alexandra Mueller.
“That adds to the confusion,” she told TechNewsWorld. “These systems seem highly capable — and they are — but their capabilities aren’t a replacement for a driver. That message seems to get lost.”
“These systems are not self-driving,” she said. “They frequently encounter conditions that require driver intervention.”
Mueller maintained the idea that drivers always have to be ready to intervene and be prepared to supervise these systems isn’t something that humans are very good at doing. “We’re not very good at maintaining the alertness to supervise and monitor what these technologies are doing constantly,” she said.
“The more capable these systems are, the more difficult it is to supervise them because the driver isn’t physically involved in the operation of the vehicle anymore,” she continued.
“It’s natural that people would want to do other things to stay alert, but doing anything but driving means the driver is no longer involved in driving the vehicle.”
If there’s one thing humans are not good at, it’s supervising automation, Abuelsamid contended. “Anytime something is working most of the time, humans will get complacent,” he said.
“It’s hard to remain mentally engaged in a task you’re not physically engaged in,” he continued. “By allowing the driver to go hands-free, you’re reducing some of the traditional driver workloads, but you’re creating new cognitive workloads for the brain.”
“No one has figured out how to address that,” he maintained. “It may be that anything less than full automation may not be a good idea.”
Driver-assisting systems can be an invitation for distracted driving. “If you tell consumers they can take their hands off the steering wheel and their foot off the pedals and the vehicle will operate itself, you’re inviting them to not pay attention,” Ramsey observed.
On the other hand, he pointed out that even without these systems, distracted drivers are everywhere. “People are already driving distracted by their phones, so these technologies have become necessary to prevent accidents,” he said. “The systems are accommodating distractions that are already there.”
Boor maintained that the auto industry needs a better way to communicate with consumers about the capabilities of driver-assistance systems. “We can’t continue to rely on the dealer or the owner’s manual,” she said.
“No one part of the automotive industry can do this alone,” she continued. “The automakers play a critical part in that, but as a whole, consumers aren’t differentiating between these levels of automation.”
“It’s critical for the industry as a whole to provide multiple learning opportunities to close that gap,” she added.
Abuelsamid advocates adding active driver monitoring systems to ensure drivers are attentive to road conditions while a driver-assistance system is activated.
“Knowing what the limitations of a system are and putting in place systems to minimize the potential for customer misuse is really critical,” he warned.
John P. Mello Jr. has been an ECT News Network reporter since 2003. His areas of focus include cybersecurity, IT issues, privacy, e-commerce, social media, artificial intelligence, big data and consumer electronics. He has written and edited for numerous publications, including the Boston Business Journal, the Boston Phoenix, Megapixel.Net and Government Security News. Email John.
Please sign in to post or reply to a comment. New users create a free account.
I will use Twitter more.
I will use Twitter less.
I will use Twitter the same as before Musk took over.
I have not used Twitter, but I will consider it now.
I have not and will not use Twitter, regardless of who is in charge.
I have used Twitter but now I am done with it.
Attacks on Cloud Service Providers Down 25% During First 4 Months of 2022
Canonical Lets Loose Ubuntu 22.04 LTS ‘Jammy Jellyfish’
Low-Code Platforms Help Ease the Shadow IT Adversity Pain
Compelling Tech Products To Put on Your Holiday Shopping Radar
Live Commerce, Shoppable Videos Turn Viewers Into Buyers
Poly Studio P5 Packs Professional Webcam Properties
Infineon’s OktoberTech Event Zeroes In on Decarbonization, Digitalization
AMD vs. Intel: Suddenly the Desktop PC Is in Play
Electronics Will Cost More in 2023
New ‘Tux’ Desktop Release Dresses Up Linux’s Distro Closet
Massive Typosquatting Racket Pushes Malware at Windows, Android Users
Twisted Cyber Case Finds Former Uber Security Chief Guilty of Data Breach Coverup
New Report Finds Nearly 50% of 2021 Phishing Targeting Gov’t Workers Aimed at Credential Theft
CEO Fired Over Employee Monitoring Among Forrester Privacy Predictions for 2023
BlackBerry: How Ukraine Is Making Us More Secure
Security Demands Shifting Business Backups Away From On-Prem Boxes
Data Observability’s Big Challenge: Build Trust at Scale
The Business Case for Clean Data and Governance Planning
Google Cloud Introduces New AI-Powered Medical Imaging Suite
Coding Vulnerabilities, Linux Growth, FOSS Friction Cap Summer Highlights
Leapwork CEO: No-Code Platforms Democratize Testing Automation
Lenovo and How ‘Star Trek: The Next Generation’ Got the Holodeck Wrong
Metaverse Maybe a Moneymaker for Enterprises by 2027
Solar Lantern Inventor Brings Ecofriendly Light to Toxic Darkness
B2B Funding Firms Banking on Embedded Finance
Unresolved Conflicts Slow eSIM Upgrade Path to Better IoT Security
Cryptocurrency Custody Concerns: Who Holds the Digital Storage Keys?
Research Finds Potential Benefits for Pre-Teen Video Game Players
Intehill 15.6″ Portable Monitor Is Masterful at Work and Play
Cloud Gaming Poised for Takeoff
Avoid Being the Next Victim of Account Takeover Fraud
Report Finds Biometric Data Threatened by Social Media
Social Media Account Hijacking Jumps 1,000% in Last 12 Months: Report
Researchers Find Consumer Satisfaction Remains High for PCs and TVs
How To Configure Windows To Auto Restart After a Power Failure
How Not To Do CX, Lenovo Style
Apple Refreshes Product Lines, Introduces New Ultra Watch
Meta Moves To Back Off Removing Covid Misinformation From Platforms
Hack Your Metabolism To Improve Health With the Lumen Smart Device
Amazon Astro Is Cute, Spunky, Not Quite Ready for Prime Time
Nest Cam’s Unique Battery and Solar Power Options
The Coming Wave of Next-Generation Home Solar Companies
5 Cyber Safety Tips To Survive the Internet, Hackers and Scammers
6 Signs Cybercriminals Infected Your Phone and How To Fix It
Start Here When Things Go Wrong on Your Linux System
Ubuntu Core 22 Release Addresses Challenges of IoT, Edge Computing
Foundries and Arduino Team To Patch IoT Devices
Remote Work Heightens Privacy and Security Anxiety Among Employees
Schneider Electric Ups the Ante on Smart Energy Management
The Fascinating ESG Difference Between Michael Dell and Elon Musk
Tech Whistleblowers Prefer Loud Exit To Quiet Quitting
Chinese Hackers Deploy Fake News Site To Infect Government, Energy Targets
Digital Devices of Corporate Brass Ripe for Hacker Attacks
New Software Vulnerability Zeroes In on Microsoft Programs
The Future of Satellite Phone Communications
Qualcomm and the Mobile Video Game Revolution
Apple Shows Off Vast Upgrades to Software, Hardware, User Experiences at WWDC22
Linux Mint 21 Release Brings Reviewer a Welcome Reunion
New Linux Laptop Line Advances HP, System76 Open-Source Collaboration
Titan Linux Beta Brings Simplicity, Finesse to KDE Remake
Maintaining Global Compliance With Modern Data Privacy Laws
Hackers Cast LinkedIn as Most-Popular Phishing Spot
PII of Many Fortune 1000 Execs Exposed at Data Broker Sites
KYY 15.6″ Portable Monitor Packs Value With a Healthy Feature Set
InnoView’s 15.6″ 4K Portable Panel Could Be the Ultimate Touchscreen Accessory
Rebuilding Ukraine: 3D Printing and the Metaverse Could Help Create the Cities of Tomorrow
DARPA Moves Forward With Project To Revolutionize Satellite Communication
Science, Art Inspire Women in Tech Entrepreneurship
Why Commercial Space Travel Is Unlikely To Scale Up
Upstart Search Engine Andi Delivers Answers, Not Lists
Microsoft Bing, Yandex Create New Search Protocol
Google Cloud Seeks To Cure Retailers’ Search Woes, Help Compete With Amazon
Linux Security Study Reveals When, How You Patch Matters
Cyber Asset Management Overwhelming IT Security Teams
30 Years of Linux History Told via Distros
Kids’ Screen Use Sees Fastest Rise in 4 Years
InnoView 15.8″ Portable Display: More Screen Space for Small Devices
What’s in Store for Next-Gen Digital Wallets
A Third of US Social Media Users Creating Fake Accounts
Amazon Lawsuit Fingers Facebook Groups Recruiting Fake Reviewers
Big Tech Firms Move To Squash Deceptive Info on Ukraine Crisis
Nvidia Launches Earth 2 and Goes to War Against Climate Change
Kuo Predicts ‘iPhone 13’ Will Support Satellite Calls and Texting
30 Years Later, the Trajectory of Linux Is Star Bound
An EV Charger Installation Odyssey
Grocery Home Delivery May Ride on Cold Chain Technology
High-Tech Trends in Law Enforcement and Emergency Response
Color, Android Apps Change the Game for E-Paper Tablets
Nvidia and the 3D Future of the Internet
Apple Refreshes iPhone SE, iPad Air, Debuts Studio Desktop
Killing Twitter, With Tesla as Collateral Damage
Musk-Twitter, Qualcomm-Apple, Netflix-Microsoft: Deciphering the Insanity
The World Is Not Yet Ready for Electric Cars
Marketers: Beware Florida’s Mini-TCPA
New EU Law Will Force Google, Meta, Others To Expose Algorithms
US-Led Seizure of RaidForums May Defy Lasting Effect on Security
IIHS Study Finds Drivers Confused About Motor Vehicle Automation
Intel and How Autonomous Driving Will Fix the Electric Car Problem
Lucid, Nvidia and the Rapidly Changing Future of Electric Cars
VR Platforms Deliver Metaverse-Style Experiences to Online Shopping
Nvidia and Disney Can Breathe Life Into the Metaverse
The Metaverse Future: Are You Ready To Become a God?
Apple MR Specs Will Shun Metaverse: Report
Apple Wearables Holiday Sales Knock It Out of the Park
Tesla Smartphone Could Be a Game Changer
Cybercriminals Employing Specialists To Maximize Ill-Gotten Gains
Encouraging Research Finds Brain Adjusts to ‘Third Thumb’
E-Commerce Tending to Health and Wellness Needs
Copyright 1998-2022 ECT News Network, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Enter your Username and Password to sign in.